Richard asked some key questions in a forum post that inspired me to reflect on my journey through BDSM and the challenges I've faced. I've written some about my first struggles with BDSM, and my sadism
here. I don't think it needs re-hashing.
One of the questions that really inspired thought was this:
Do you ever fear it is a questionable addiction? Perhaps one day you will push too far or expect more than is wise?
When I was younger, BDSM really was an addiction. I used it as self-medication in much the way one would use drugs and alcohol, with the same results. It was more the sadism than the dominance, but I couldn't get past the craving to inflict pain. As with all addictions, it rapidly took over my life, causing me to put myself in situations that could have been very damaging to me, and to everyone around me. It also became more and more difficult to attain the level of bliss I needed to calm myself and stop the destructive behavior. The need for it grew, my tolerance level grew, and the amount of pain and fear I had to inflict to sate myself grew as well. As with many addictions, it took outside intervention to help me realize that what I had wasn’t what I really wanted or needed.
It has taken a lot of hard work, self-examination, healing of inner wounds, and time for me to be comfortable in my skin. Sadism and dominance is woven throughout my being. I can't separate the two, any more than I can just stop being one or the other, or both. Even the most sensual pleasure with a partner, for me, has some level of infliction of pain involved, either physical or psychological. On the extremely rare occasions that I've been the bottom, there is still pain, and I never truly slip out of my innate dominance. I'm not capable of a purely "vanilla" relationship, any more than a person who has been blind from birth is capable of accurately describing various shades of a color.
I do fear losing my balance, not in the sense of an addiction, or in that I will move into a state of a constant need for satiation of both my sensual and sadistic tendencies regardless of my health, sanity, or any sense of responsibility. I am very aware that I have the capacity to give in utterly to that inner beast, to become consumed by it, and to thoroughly enjoy the sensations of doing so. In times of stress, we tend to revert to the most basic of our wiring and components, and my basic pieces lack elements that are common to a majority of people. I do not regret inflicting intentional pain—I revel in it. I don't worry about how I am perceived by those around me. I'm not burdened by guilt, so modifying my behavior to avoid it never occurs to me. Empathy, sympathy, a sense of what is right and what is wrong… all of these are things that I have worked hard to learn about, to be able to experience, and they only work for me if I have balance in my life.
I fear that the iron discipline I employ when playing with someone that can't physically or emotionally handle my intensity will slip. I think that for a sadist such as myself, that particular fear is a very real one, with potential disastrous consequences. If I allow myself the luxury of slipping those controls, I could very seriously damage a playmate, and would find it sexually arousing and fulfilling to do so, instead of the "normal" reaction of guilt or remorse.
One of the reasons that my darker fantasies are so very dark to me isn't that they involve brutality and degradation on a scale that is beyond healthy play… it is because I know that I could make those fantasies a reality and not suffer the pangs of conscience or morality that others would. That is a line I am not willing to cross.
I've been asked over the years by family members and friends, and a few strangers, what it is that causes me to be both sadistic and dominant. I don't know. I don't have any deeply buried unresolved childhood traumas, no key tipping points in development. I'm just who I was as a child, with hopefully a bit more refinement, grace, and patience. I've always naturally been a leader instead of a follower, more dominant than the other kids, and have learned through experience to hone those things that make me strong and discard the things that leave me weak or exposed or vulnerable.